Handling Low-Ball Home Offers: Tips for Wilmington Home Sellers

Married couple looking at tablet

Despite high buyer demand and low inventory in the Wilmington real estate market, it’s not uncommon to receive a low-ball offer from a buyer. We saw a quick and large increase in home values, and buyers are still struggling to reconcile what people are paying for homes now compared to 3 years ago. As a seller, it is essential to approach these offers with a strategic mindset to ensure you get the best deal possible for your home. Selling a home can be an emotional process, especially if you’ve lived in the house for a long time or have invested in significant upgrades. Receiving an offer below your expectations can be disheartening, but it’s crucial to remember that negotiation is a standard part of the home-selling process.

Stay Calm

The first step in handling a low-ball offer is to stay calm and composed. Take a deep breath and remind yourself that the buyer’s offer is not a personal attack on the value of your home. Emotions can cloud judgment, so it’s essential to approach the situation objectively. Assess your expectations and remove any emotional attachment you have to the property.

Remember, your primary goal as a home seller is to maximize your profit and get the best possible price for your home. On the other hand, the buyer’s goal is to acquire the property for the lowest price the market will allow. Keep in mind that the initial offer is merely the starting point for negotiations. By staying calm and collected, you’ll be better equipped to respond thoughtfully and strategically to the offer.

Review Recently Sold Homes Similar to Yours

One effective way to gauge the fairness of a low-ball offer is to conduct research on recently sold homes that are comparable to yours. Take note of properties with similar features, size, location, and condition. If you find that comparable homes have recently sold for a lower price, the buyer’s offer may be justified based on market trends.

In such cases, it may be more realistic to consider the current market conditions and adjust your price expectations accordingly. On the other hand, if you discover that homes similar to yours are selling at or near your desired price, you can use this data to support a counteroffer. Presenting evidence of comparable sales can help justify your asking price and demonstrate to the buyer that your valuation is fair and reasonable.

Consider Your Goals and Needs

While comparable home sales are essential in determining the market value of your property, they are not the only factor to consider. As a home seller, you likely have your own unique goals and needs that may influence your decision-making.

For instance, if you’re not in a rush to sell and can afford to wait for a more suitable offer, you may be less inclined to lower your listing price significantly. However, if you’re facing financial constraints or need to move for a new job or school, you might be more motivated to negotiate closer to the buyer’s offer.

Before making any decisions, take the time to evaluate your personal circumstances and financial requirements. This self-assessment will help you make informed choices during negotiations and strike a balance between your goals and the market’s conditions.

Counter the Offer

Upon receiving a low-ball offer, it’s natural to feel offended or dismissive. However, responding with anger or ignoring the offer entirely is not a productive approach. Always make a counteroffer, even if it seems far from what you’re willing to accept. Counteroffers are an integral part of the negotiation process and can lead to meaningful discussions with the buyer.

In some cases, buyers may make a low offer to test your willingness to negotiate. They might have a higher budget and be open to paying more for the right property. By making a counteroffer, you signal your willingness to engage in further discussions and demonstrate that you value their interest in your home.

When countering, focus not only on the price but also consider other incentives or terms that may improve your net profit. For example, you could negotiate repairs, closing costs, or other contingencies that could sweeten the deal for both parties. Be open to creative solutions that align with your goals as a seller.

Stay Pleasant

Negotiations can be challenging, but maintaining a positive and pleasant attitude can make a significant difference. Building a rapport with the buyer and their agent can create a more cooperative and harmonious negotiation process. Staying friendly and approachable can encourage the buyer to be more receptive to your counteroffers and potentially lead to a compromise that satisfies both parties.

Remember that a lot happens between offer acceptance and closing. If the buyers feel they’re going to have a positive experience during the sale, they’ll be more willing to compromise on price, repairs, and other terms. However, if the buyer isn’t being amicable or is pushing for unreasonable demands, you can always choose not to accept their offer.

Be aware that once you officially sign the Purchase Agreement, you’re bound by its terms. Thus, it’s better to reject an offer before signing if you find that the terms are not suitable for your needs or expectations.


Handling low-ball offers requires a combination of strategic thinking, market awareness, and effective communication. When faced with a low offer, take the time to analyze comparable sales, evaluate your goals, and make informed decisions. Engage in constructive negotiations with a counteroffer that reflects both your interests and the market’s conditions.

Always remember to maintain a positive and pleasant demeanor throughout the process, as this can foster a more cooperative atmosphere and lead to a successful transaction. Before proceeding with any offer, it’s essential to discuss all the terms of the Offer to Purchase Agreement with your real estate agent. A clear understanding of your responsibilities and the terms of termination will help you navigate the negotiation process with confidence and clarity.

As you navigate the process of selling your home in the Wilmington real estate market, remember that having a knowledgeable and experienced real estate agent by your side can be invaluable. Your agent can provide valuable insights, guide you through negotiations, and ensure you make informed decisions that align with your objectives as a home seller. Happy selling!

Handling Low-Ball Home Offers Pin

How to handle low-ball offers from buyers when selling your home.

About the Author
Meghan Henderson
Meghan is the Marketing Specialist for The Cameron Team and a published author of two young adult books. She also creates digital and printable planners and trackers, as well as coloring pages for Larkspur & Tea.